Defensive Play Calling based on Score and Time Remaining

Greg and I have been using essentially the same method of play for quite some time. Part of the method of play included a defensive play calling chart for Neutral Downs (Fletch67) and then situational downs. You can find the chart here… https://oguard62.net/method-of-play/. The play calling chart is on page 14.

For years, I have always used the defensive play calling chart throughout the entire game regardless of score and time remaining and most of the time it worked well, but admittedly it always felt wonky (is that a word) when a team was trailing or leading by a wide margin late in the game. I then came across this post on ABTL, https://forums.delphiforums.com/apbabtl/messages/?msg=71460.468

Mark Dergarabedian asked Greg the very question I had been thinking about and it seems my Brother had been holding out on me and was actually using the situational down chart when a team had a two score lead with 5:00 minutes remaining in the 4th quarter. That motivated me to come up with an expanded version of Greg’s idea and came up with the following:

The * defensive alignment being referred to is 3rd/4th down and >=8 yards and ** defensive alignment refers to the 3rd/4th down & 1 yard to go on the situational downs chart. If using the Master Game the reduction rule is also triggered on the * defensive alignment. All audibles, blitzes and keying as described in the Method of Play are in effect. When calling defenses when down, essentially playing to stop the run, ignore the QB Sneak audible unless it is 3rd/4th and 1.

In all situations it is assumed that the trailing team will be calling a pass on every down, and the leading team will run on every down. The audible system would take care of any counter plays, like draws or screens. If you choose to play without the audible system then it is recommended to revert back to the Fletch67 system otherwise you are just, well, “playing with yourself”.

I hope you all find this useful, and I am sure many of you will come up with modification based on your own method of play. The goal here was to give a guide to dealing with playing calls based on score in the 4th quarter.

Automated Penalty Charts

Mark Zarb has created charts to accurately represent the various types of penalties, infraction yardage, and enforcement notes to assist with stat keeping for seasons ranging from the late 1950s to modern day.  To prevent an excess of individual season charts, Mark has created three automated files for rapid callup for the following eras:

  • Pre-1974
  • 1974 – 2004
  • Modern Era

Under the Penalties tab in the “Modern Era” spreadsheet, I’ve inserted notes in the Penalty Table section referencing the year the penalty came into effect to assist the replayer. For example, Chop Block (2016), Illegal Blind Side Block (2019), etc.

These charts were designed to work in conjunction with his Penalty innovation. To use without having the applicable season ratings, it’s a simple two-step process:

The below files have been added to the Add-ons section under Mark Zarb:

Pre-1974 Automated Penalty Chart

1974 – 2004 Automated Penalty Chart

Modern Era Automated Penalty Chart

“Trick Play” Formula

Mark Zarb was kind enough to allow me to release his “Trick Play” formula into the public domain. I’ve had the pleasure of using it for the past 12 replays and absolutely love it. I’m always amazed at how nearly each teams trick play attempt is accounted for. Traditionally, it’s the head coach that has the final say if a trick play is called and it’s no different on my tabletop. For example, if a “Fake Punt” comes up and the situation is unrealistic (backed up deep into my own territory, 4th and long situations, etc), I simply ignore it. The best part is that all trick plays are randomly selected to eliminate “gaming of the system”.

Step-by-step instructions are listed in the below standalone file. I hope that you enjoy this system as much as I have.

Trick Play Formula

“Thanksgiving Memories”

As my 2015 NFL replay gets ready for the Thanksgiving slot of games, I couldn’t help but think of the wonderful day my best friend, Mark Zarb, and I had together watching those games, enjoying Becky’s turkey and having a few drinks. It was a treat to be able to grill out a “cowboy cut ribeyes” on Black Friday but unfortunately I had to cut the trip short and fly down to Florida to deal with my ailing mother. The below picture was from the previous Thanksgiving.

Thanksgiving (Mark and Greg)

Full Circle – 1968 AFL/NFL Replay

It seems like yesterday that I was searching EBAY for some APBA Football cards only to come across a listing for a 1968 AFL/NFL APBA card set compatible with the modern football game created by some gentleman named Mark Zarb. Of course, being a life-long New York Jets fan, I couldn’t believe my luck. Upon receiving the card set, I noticed Mark Zarb’s contact information at the bottom of the introduction letter and reached out to him. How would I know that I just found my brother from another mother? We both are life-long, die-hard, suffering New York Jet fans with a passion for the realism of APBA Football.

https://oguard62.net/article-authored-by-g-giordano/

While Mark was still selling cards, I purchased and eventually replayed the 1967, 1974, and 1981 seasons. When he got out of the business, he took a hiatus from the hobby for a couple of years but not from our friendship. We routinely communicated and eventually I convinced him to come visit me down in Huntsville, Alabama in March, 2014.

https://oguard62.net/2014/03/17/apba-football-brothers/

That visit was pivotal because it brought him back into the fold as a card maker and a replayer. Since then, he has carded and replayed the following seasons: 1972, 1981 (revised from original) and 1978. In addition, he carded and is currently working on replaying the 2010 campaign. In between numerous Thanksgivings and Iron Bowls, Jet games, innovation discussions, fine-dining, and countless Crown Royal and Tanqueray’s together, he found the time to card me 1985, 1969 and 1998 seasons for my replaying pleasure.

I find it only fitting, that my tenth full-season replay will be the 1968 AFL/NFL season. Just for clarification purposes, this will not be conducted with the original set that I purchased all those years ago. This is a brand new set based off of “lessons learned” from the eleven football seasons that Mark has carded and well over a 1,000 play-tested games which have validated the innovations and methodology that we employ.

Macro or Auto-Sort “Standings”

In this corner, we have the number 1 contender, Auto-sort, versus the champion, Macros, in a title bout for the “Most User-friendly APBA Football Standings”. In this title bout the APBA Football community is the winner because both methods are tremendous timesavers. I’m always looking for ways to improve all facets (preparation, method of play, data input and reporting) of my replays and am blessed to have really smart friends. Denny Hodge created the auto-sort version and my APBA Football brother, Mark Zarb, created the macro-version.

These standings are designed to use in conjunction with the team workbooks that I posted a few days back. All you have to do is link each teams win, loss, tie, points scored and points allowed to the template. If using the auto-sort workbook, just link to gray-colored section.

Usage is very simple, for the auto-sort just open the file and the standings automatically adjust for each team’s winning percentage. For the macro version, just simultaneously press CTRL R keys and each divisions winning percentage is sorted. Press a second time and each divisions win record is sorted and press a third time and each division is alphabetically for teams with identical records. These functions happen a mind-numbing speed.

I know which one is my favorite but they are both winners in my book! Unfortunately WordPress doesn’t allow macro files to be inserted into a post but if interested email me at greg.barath@oguard62.net and I will send you the file.

2002 Standings(auto sort)

Tweaks to Existing Innovations & Introducing a New One

For several years now, Mark Zarb and I have corroborated numerous innovations and ideas with regard to APBA Football. Mark is the “brains”, he comes up with the conceptual ideas and transforms them into procedures or innovations. I apply those ideas/innovations to my replays to determine the effectiveness. Now, that Mark is playing full-time, we have double the data points to determine if it “works or not”.

The primary reason I replayed the 1969 AFL season was to be able to compare the statistics of the two replays. The following is the four objectives that I evaluated:

Objective 1. Assess adjustment to Fletch67 defensive ratings and Key against the Run.

Objective 2. Assess change to Double Coverage (Keying) formula for both Neutral and Situational downs.

Objective 3. Assess if change to “Situational Down and Distance” chart affected opponent’s ability to convert third down.

Objective 4. Assess frequency and playability of new “Pass Rush Impact” innovation.

Test Report