Updated “Method of Play”

Being a student of the game, I’m always trying to fine-tune my playing method to increase speed of play and obtain realistic statistics. I’ve revised my “Method of Play” to reflect my latest playing techniques. The primary changes are to limit rusher’s to their actual long for specific situations, revised quota for “Rare Plays”, simple solo method for determining “Trick Play” defense, and modified goal line techniques.

The update presentation can be found under “Method of Play” in upper ribbon.

“Trick Play” Defense

While conducting my current 1967 replay, I’ve noticed that the “halfback pass” was used at a greater frequency compared to today’s game. This sparked a conversation between Mark Zarb and me regarding “Trick Plays”. During our talk, it was identified that my current “Method of Play” doesn’t address a “Trick Play Defense”. To rectify this, I will be implementing his simple but effective method for determining if a “Trick Play” defense was called.

Here is how a called “Trick Play” will look like on my tabletop. Once per half, I have the option to call a trick play (i.e., bootleg, end around, non-QB pass, etc.) against a standard or nickel defense when replaying modern seasons. Roll the dice and if the result is 11, 33, or 66, the defense called a “Trick Play Defense” and I will score the play as a 7-yard rushing loss by the ball carrier, intended passer or punter. .

APBA Football “Brothers”

 

This past weekend I was lucky enough to play host to my dear friend, Mark Zarb.  Our friendship was forged several years ago through our shared love of APBA Football and the New York Jets.  Over the last two-days, we enjoyed countless hours talking APBA Football.  Our discussions ranged from the intricacies of card making, Phil Molloy’s allocation system and Read-Option innovation, criteria associated with determining team ratings, extensive review of statistics from my 2011 NFL replay and an evaluation of several quarterback cards from the 2011 set.  Mark was extremely impressed with look of the new cards and that every player was carded.  However, we both wish APBA would quit carding kickers/punters with a fumble number who never had an actual fumble but besides that he came to the same conclusion that I did several months back, that whoever is carding the modern football seasons is doing a really good job. 

One card that we spent a lot of time reviewing was Aaron Rodgers.  The top line of the stat sheet is the result of my replay and the bottom line is actuals.   

       

Pct

Yards

   

Had

Pct

Pct

Avg.

   
Passing:  

Att

Com

Com

Gained

TD

Long

Int.

TD

Int

Gain

Rating

Fum

Rodgers Replay

502

365

72.7

4678

36

68

7

7.2

1.4

9.3

119.6

3

  Actual

502

343

68.3

4643

45

93

6

9.0

1.2

9.2

122.5

5.0

I was very pleased how Aaron Rodgers performed for me but Mark was concerned about the touchdown disparity.  So for the next 2-hours I had the pleasure of being “Behind the Curtain” and watched him card Aaron Rodgers.  I joked with him that people would pay good money to be sitting in my chair but I came away with even a greater appreciation for the pain staking effort that goes into carding a set.  I won’t post his results but they were slightly different than Rodger’s official card.

Afterwards, Mark wanted to watch me “roll a game” of my current replay.  So I took him to Memorial Stadium and he watched the Baltimore Colts take on the Los Angeles Rams. Besides the bantering back and forth and the countless laughs, he thoroughly enjoyed watching firsthand the impact his innovations had on the game.  For instance, Roman Gabriel tossed 5 interceptions in the game with two of them coming off of the Colts +13 interception rating.  On another occasion, I rolled a “Full Fumble” number (33) on a Ram’s player, however, after consulting the “Forced Fumble” table it was determined that another dice roll was required and if the result was 24-66 the fumble would stand.  I rolled a 22 nullifying the fumble and jokingly said the Colts just got “Zarbed”.  Trust me when I say, Roman Gabriel is still muttering it under his breath.  On countless occasions, he witnessed the power of the “Yards per Catch” innovation, especially with Jack Snow.

The following day, he watched me roll a game between the Boston Patriots and the Miami Dolphins.  In real life, the Patriots routed the Dolphins 41-10 and the replay didn’t disappoint with the Dolphins getting crushed 48–14.  I kept telling him how Babe Parilli has enjoyed “hot dice” during this replay and Mark guaranteed me that the Babe would toss 3 interceptions against the Dolphins.  Parilli opened the game going 7 for 7 with dice rolls of 11, 22, 66, 44 (laughs) and he finished with only 1 interception.  Needless to say, Babe Parilli is still mocking Mark Zarb.

In the below photo, Mark Zarb is on the left and I am on the right. 

Mark Zarb - Greg Barath

APBA Convention

This year’s APBA Convention will be held on June 20-22, 2014 at the Hilton Garden Inn Atlanta North/Alpharetta.  I’ve noticed several inquiries either on the Delphi Forums or APBA Football Club’s Facebook page whether there will be any type of football presence there during the event.

Last week I reached out to John Herson through Kevin Cluff to see if he would mind if “Football guys” like me socialized and played some Face-to-Face games in the same room as the tournament.  Not knowing the size of the room and not wanting to be a distraction, I thought it was important to get John’s blessing.  I received the below email from Kevin the next day.

” I talked to John about this and he was fine with it as long as you are willing to organize the games (or tourney, whatever you end up doing).  Assuming we get the same room as last year there should be no problem with the football games going on, at the same time.  Personally, I think it is a great idea, and I am looking forward to meeting you this year!”

I reached out to Ray Dunlap to enlist his services and assistance.  Ray brought up a really interesting point, he’s convinced the reason the football game is not nearly as popular as the baseball game is that the game company’s solo version is not up to par.  If more gamers knew about superior ways to play the football game solo, I think we could recruit an entirely new generation of converts. He asked me to play at least a quarter to demonstrate my playing technique and various innovations that I employ.  In turn, Ray will demonstrate his outstanding “Match-Up” system.  Without knowing how many interested people will attend, I can’t promise that there will be an organized tournament, however, there will be the opportunity for several “Face-to-Face” games.

Now that you know that there will be a Football presence at the APBA Convention, go-ahead and sign up for the convention (pre-order cost is $110.00) at http://apbagames.com/2014-convention.  For me, it would be a real pleasure and treat to finally meet some of the folks that I have interacted with for years on the Delphi message boards.  Hope to see you there!!

“Heidi” Game

On the APBA “Between the Lines” (BTL) forum a discussion regarding the Heidi game arose on my Oguard62’s 1967 AFL/NFL Replay thread.  The “Heidi” game took place on November 17, 1968 in a game between the New York Jets and the Oakland Raiders.  The Jets were winning 32-29 late in the game, when TV executives from NBC decided to air the movie “Heidi” instead of showing the last 2-minutes of the ball game.  As you can imagine, this created quite the uproar, NBC studio in New York City received so many calls that their circuit board blew out.  Only the 53,318 attendees at the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum got to witness Daryle Lamonica connect with Charlie Smith for a 43-yard TD followed up by Earl Christy fumbling the ensuing kickoff and Oakland’s Preston Ridlehuber recovering it for a 2-yard TD making the final score Oakland 43, New York 32.

Mr. Jim Fraasch posted the following on my 1967 thread on BTL: “I’m looking forward to how much realism Greg is able to recreate for the Heidi game when he replays 1968.” Well I have already replayed this season twice and wanted to share the results of my “Heidi” game that I played on December 27, 2010.

Heidi Game

Kickoff Table Question

I have a question associated with lines 31, 35 and 36 of the “Kickoff” table in the Master game.  There is an asterick (*) assigned to the “TL” penalty, what does this mean?  This confuses me because an “asterick” indicates how to measure the penalty (I.e., offensive clipping, holding, or illegal use of hands) associated with a kick return, but, none of results from the “L” column on the Penalty Chart are one of these type of infractions. 

If someone could shed some light on this matter it would answer a question I’ve wondered about for years.

Phil Molloy, could you please express your viewpoint on this matter?

Timing the Game – Touchbacks

As we all have read the following excerpt from Section I. Basic Instructions, paragraph H.2. “Extra point attempts do not count at all in timing the game. The following are timed as half-plays: incomplete passes, touchdowns, field goals, safeties, and all plays on which the ball changes team possession or goes out of bounds, or which involve penalties or injuries.  ALL OTHER PLAYS ARE FULL PLAYS.” 

Well, what about touchbacks?  There are several different types of touchbacks ranging from punts, blocked punt goes back into the end zone and the defensive team intentionally bats or kicks the ball out the back of the end zone, fumble goes out of bounds in opponents end zone, defensive player intercepts a pass in own end zone or on kickoffs.  I specifically want to clarify how to treat a touchback resulting from a kick off. 

Pre-2002 season. Prior to the 2002 season, the clock started on the kickoff unless it was within the last two minutes of the half.  If touchback occurred outside of the “Two-Minute” warning, the touchback will be recorded as a half-play.  If touchback occured inside the “Two-Minute” warning, do not record as half play (ignore) because the clock only starts when the ball was put into play by the receiving team.

Post-2002. Starting in 2002 the clock only starts when put into play by the receiving team and the two minute rule was eliminated. All touchbacks will not be recorded as a half-play.

“Put into play” is defined as: When a member of the receiving team touches the ball, or, if the member of the receiving team touches the ball in their end zone, carries the ball out of the end zone. The clock is stopped when that player is tackled or goes out of bounds. The clock never starts if the receiving team downs the ball in their own end zone for a touchback.

“Special Thanks” to Ray Dunlap

As I’m closing in on finishing the 2011 regular season and reviewing the teams whose season is already completed, it really makes me appreciate the flexibility that Ray Dunlap’s “Quota Chart” offers especially in the running game.  As hard as I try, it’s very difficult to replicate the exact number of carries or pass attempts for each player.  The game is going to dictate at times a player exceeding his actual attempts.  So, what is a realistic amount that a player should exceed his actual without completely skewing statistics? For me, the answer is in Ray Dunlap’s math-based system.   Like all of his other innovations, it’s very thought out, realistic and fine-tuned over years of practical application.  Thanks Ray, for this great contribution to APBA Football!!

http://oguard62.net/2012/06/09/ray-dunlaps-quota-chart/